Construction Project Management Services and Construction Books
  • Construction Home
  • About Paul Netscher
  • +Construction Books
    • Successful Construction Project Management
    • Building a Successful Construction Company
    • Construction Claims
    • Construction Project Management: Tips and Insights
    • Construction Management: From Project Concept to Completion
    • An Introduction to Building and Renovating Houses
    • The Successful Construction Supervisor and Foreman
    • Designing your ideal home
  • Construction Management Services
  • Book Reviews
  • Contact
  • Blog | Construction Management
  • Site Map
  • Blog | Home Improvement
  • Index of construction articles
  • Useful Links
  • Index Home Improvement

The Alarming Truth about Using Old Construction Equipment

7/6/2017

12 Comments

 
Picture

Using old construction equipment isn’t as cheap as you might think

The other day I was watching a mobile crane lifting items from a truck onto the roof of a 3-storey building. Now nothing unusual with this, except the operator sat in a cab which could be raised up to a height where he was level with the roof. He could see exactly where the load was being placed in the middle of the roof. He wasn’t dependent on someone talking to him on a radio or standing on the edge of the roof guiding him with hand signals. When he collected the load from the truck he was looking down into the truck and could clearly see the load. The whole operation went quicker and more safely than it would normally go with a conventional mobile crane with the operator’s cab placed a couple of metres off the ground. Furthermore, the operator wasn’t craning his head upwards at an awkward angle to see the roof 12 meters above him. He also didn’t have to look straight up into the sun.

I marvelled at how the design of construction equipment has improved over the years. I was reminded that many years ago the company I worked for operated cranes that were 20 and more years old. In fact, the head of the equipment department was proud of the fact that his team kept these old cranes running, sometimes long past their life expectancy. The cranes had been paid for several years before so the rental rates the projects were charged were nominal. Our estimating department used these low rental rates when they priced new projects which gave many projects a winning price advantage. However, this sometimes caused problems when the cranes weren’t available when the project began, and the project team found they had to hire cranes from external sources at rental rates nearly double what the estimator had budgeted in the project price.

Now it was one thing having an item of equipment that was cheap to rent, but it was another thing when the equipment broke down repeatedly. In fact, the cheap item of equipment suddenly became very expensive when teams were left standing because the crane was broken! The project was delayed. Teams had to work late to compensate for the time when the crane was out of action. Supervisors and workers became frustrated. Quality was compromised when the crane broke down in the middle of pouring concrete. Furthermore, the equipment division had to rush mechanics to the project to undertake emergency repairs. Sometimes the item couldn’t be repaired on the project and had to be transported back to the yard and a replacement item had to be ordered and shipped to the project. Costs mounted!
​
I realised the folly of using old equipment and eventually persuaded the company to purchase a new fleet of cranes which were more expensive to rent but far more reliable.

This same company had an extensive fleet of earthmoving equipment and had kept meticulous records of the maintenance and finance costs of the items. They carried out various studies relating the purchase price of new equipment, plus the cost of repairs and maintenance of the item over time, and taking into account the resale value of the item when the company sold and replaced it. Now the cost of the repairs and maintenance increased the older the item was, and the resale value decreased the more hours the machine worked. By plotting these values it was possible to work out the optimum point when the item should be replaced – after this point the item became more costly to maintain and keep. This optimum point varied between different items of equipment (excavators, loaders, graders, etc). Of course, this does generalise slightly as not every item of equipment is exactly the same, or has operated in the same conditions, or with the same operator. Indeed, I’m sure many of us have owned the dud vehicle that has given trouble from day one while others with the same vehicle haven’t had one iota of problems. Then there are other items that just seem to go on and on, as good as the first day they left the showroom.
Picture

The disadvantages of using old construction equipment

​Construction companies that own their own equipment often face challenges of deciding whether to purchase new or used items. Then when should the item be replaced? Projects that rent or hire equipment often rent the cheapest item without considering the age or reliability of the machine. Making the wrong decision can be very costly – but often these costs aren’t obvious.

​So what are the disadvantages of using older equipment?
  1. When equipment breaks down the team is left standing which impacts productivity – this can be costly as the team relying on the machine is left standing. A crane breaks and the project can’t lift materials. An excavator breaks down and the trucks it was loading are left standing.
  2. When an item is broken the project is often delayed which means the project incurs additional costs as well as risking the client imposing delay damages.
  3. Often management becomes involved with the repairs, which takes their time away from other tasks. I have known supervisors that have spent hours wrestling with a machine to get it repaired while their team has been left unsupervised. Certainly, management have to arrange repairs and replacement machines which takes time from their other duties.
  4. The project team becomes frustrated and sometimes demoralised when equipment frequently is broken. Employees may eventually leave the company in frustration causing further problems for the project.
  5. If the item is owned by the construction company then they have the cost of the repairs which could include; the cost of the repairman, the spare parts and the cost of shipping the parts to the project. Often these repairs are urgent and parts may have to be airfreighted at additional expense. The more remote the project site the more costly this exercise can be.
  6. In all of this our clients become frustrated. They want to see progress. They don’t want to see their project delayed when the contractor’s equipment frequently breaks down. Clients want to employ contractors they can rely on, and this means employing contractors that use reliable equipment.
  7. If the item cannot be immediately repaired, or it cannot be repaired on the project, it has to be transported back to the company’s equipment yard or the nearest place where it can be repaired, and a replacement item has to be taken to the project. This can be an expensive operation, particularly for large items. But sometimes it’s not as simple as this and a replacement item isn’t immediately available, or the replacement comes at a higher cost.
  8. As mentioned at the start of the article new equipment comes with new improved features which enhance the ergonomics of the machine. It could mean that the machine is more comfortable and easier to operate which results in the operator being less fatigued – which helps productivity and is better for our employees’ health. Often efficiencies and speed are enhanced which means the item can produce more and the productivity is better. Fuel efficiencies are better which reduces costs. Sometimes maintenance costs are less.
  9. A company’s equipment is an advertisement for it. Equipment with logos are often what the public sees. An older piece of equipment, leaking oil and belching smoke isn’t a good look for any company. Some of our clients complimented us on the new equipment we were using, even when these items weren’t ours, but were rented. Equipment that looks new, appears modern and is well looked after creates an impression that the company is professional and can be relied on.
  10. New equipment is safer. It normally comes with better safety features. Being new usually means it is less likely to break down or fail. But also, consider the example of the crane above – if the operator can clearly see the load at all times, it’s got to be safer than working ‘blind’, guided by someone else.
  11. New equipment is usually more environmentally friendly. Older equipment can leak oil and when hydraulic hoses break there is often a major spill which must be cleaned up. Older equipment is often noisier and belch smoke which is detrimental to workers as well as neighbours and the public. As mentioned earlier older equipment often uses more fuel.
  12. The resale value of the equipment decreases with the age of the machine, while the maintenance costs increase.
Picture

Choosing the right construction equipment

Construction companies need to carefully consider whether to purchase new equipment or previously used equipment. Then they should consider when to replace the item. These decisions can have major financial consequences as well as impacting the success of their projects. In some cases, when the company doesn’t have the financial ability to purchase a new machine, or a replacement item, it may be better not to own the item, but to rather rent the item from an external provider.

​Projects should carefully consider when they hire equipment for the project whether the cheapest item available is really going to be the best, and ultimately the cheapest item for their work. A broken piece of equipment can be very costly and disruptive to the project.
​#constructionequipment #constructionmachines #constructionmanagement #contractors 
Picture
​This article was first published on the ClockShark website. 
Please share this post
To read more about the author’s books and find out where you can purchase them visit the pages on this website by clicking the links below:
'Successful Construction Project Management: The Practical Guide'
'Building a Successful Construction Company: The Practical Guide'
'Construction Claims: A Short Guide for Contractors'
'Construction Project Management: Tips and Insights'
'Construction Book reviews'

To read more about the author visit the page 'Paul Netscher'
Want to contact Paul Netscher please enter your details on 'Contacts'

Find out how Paul Netscher can help you

Order your books from Amazon
Order your books from Amazon UK

© 2017 This article is not to be reproduced for commercial purposes without written permission from the author.
Picture

The other day I was watching a mobile crane lifting items from a truck onto the roof of a 3-story building. Now nothing unusual with this, except the operator sat in a cab which could be raised up to a height where he was actually level with the roof. He could see exactly where the load was being placed in the middle of the roof. He wasn’t dependent on someone talking to him on a radio or standing on the edge of the roof guiding him with hand signals. When he collected the load from the truck he was looking down into the truck and could clearly see the load. The whole operation went quicker and more safely than it would normally go with a conventional mobile crane with the operator’s cab placed a couple of meters off the ground. Furthermore, the operator wasn’t craning his head upwards at an awkward angle to see the roof 12 meters above him. He also didn’t have to look straight up into the sun.

I marveled at how the design of construction equipment has improved over the years. I was reminded that many years ago the company I worked for operated cranes that were 20 and more years old. In fact, the head of the equipment department took particular pride at how his team kept these old cranes running, sometimes long past their life expectancy. The cranes had been paid for many years ago so the rental rates the projects were charged were nominal. Our estimating department used these low rental rates when they priced new projects which gave many projects a winning price advantage. However, this sometimes caused problems when the cranes weren’t available when the project began, and the project team found they had to hire cranes from external sources at rental rates nearly double what the estimator had budgeted in the project price.

Now it was one thing having an item of equipment that was cheap to rent, but it was another thing when the equipment broke down repeatedly. In fact, the cheap item of equipment suddenly became very expensive when teams were left standing because the crane was broken! The project was delayed. Teams had to work late to compensate for the time when the crane was out of action. Supervisors and workers became frustrated. Quality was compromised when the crane broke down in the middle of pouring concrete. Furthermore, the equipment division had to rush mechanics to the project to undertake emergency repairs. Sometimes the item couldn’t be repaired on the project and had to be transported back to the yard and a replacement item had to be ordered and shipped to the project. Costs mounted!

I realized the folly of using old equipment and eventually persuaded the company to purchase a new fleet of cranes which were more expensive to rent but far more reliable.
This same company had an extensive fleet of earth-moving equipment and had kept meticulous records of the maintenance and finance costs of the items. They carried out various studies relating the purchase price of new equipment, plus the cost of repairs and maintenance of the item over time and taking into account the resale value of the item when the company sold and replaced it. Now the cost of the repairs and maintenance increased the older the item was, and the resale value decreased the more hours the machine worked. By plotting these values it was possible to work out the optimum point when the item should be replaced – after this point the item became more costly to maintain and keep. This optimum point varied between different items of equipment (excavators, loaders, graders, etc). Of course, this does generalize slightly as not every item of equipment is exactly the same, or has operated in the same conditions, or with the same operator. Indeed I’m sure many of us have owned the dud vehicle that has given trouble from day one while others with the same vehicle haven’t had one iota of problems. Then there are other items that just seem to go on and on, as good as the first day they left the showroom. 

Picture
construction management construction project management
12 Comments
Bob link
19/12/2020 10:20:02 am

https://www.pn-projectmanagement.com/construction-management-blog/the-alarming-truth-about-using-old-construction-equipment

Reply
Tez link
11/3/2021 11:14:30 am

Great tip about how you will need to make repairs to the crane over time. I need to get a crane for part of my home remodel. I plan to use it to set a new roof down.

Reply
Chris Pederson link
25/3/2021 04:18:34 am

Thanks for making it clear how it isn't cheaper to use old construction equipment. No one should use old equipment unless it is certified to be safe. People should not be put in danger in order to save a couple of bucks.

Reply
Taylor Hicken link
8/7/2021 12:53:19 pm

I appreciated it when you shared that the quality of work was compromised when a crane broke down in the middle of the project. Hence, it is very important to acquire a well-maintained equipment that will less likely to break down. I would like to think if a company needs to use a crane for its project, it should consider renting from a reliable service.

Reply
Mobile Crane HIre link
11/8/2021 10:42:48 pm

I believe in the saying dont fix what isn't broken.(correct me if im wrong) Though these items are 20 years old. They're bound to fail, nothing lasts forever. However we should try adapt into the new ways.

Reply
Chance Cook link
1/9/2021 09:33:08 pm

I can only imagine how much it must cost to have your team sitting around while the machine is broken down. That would honestly drive me crazy. I hope that I never have to deal with that so I'll stick to buying new equipment.

Reply
Overhead Crane Training Edmonton link
9/11/2021 11:57:57 pm

It goes without saying that upgrading an equipment can make your business more functional, increase jobsite productivity, reduce downtime, ensure safety of workers and improve overall efficiency.

Reply
Rick Jones link
29/1/2022 07:00:56 am

I can see having a crane that is paid off would allow for nominal charging. A rental service could then charge less on the cranes that aren't paid off. This would benefit everyone.

Reply
Henry Killingsworth link
3/6/2022 02:42:44 am

It was interesting when you talked about how old construction equipment can cause project delays. If you are looking to purchase new construction equipment, it seems like it would be a good idea to sell your old machines first. Selling your machines would probably be a good way to raise the money you need for new equipment.

Reply
Victoria Addington link
25/8/2022 08:29:07 am

It was most captivating when you mentioned the project gets delayed when the equipment broke down repeatedly. My friend needs a rigging lifting service to finish their project on time. I should advise him to work with a contractor that deploys expert personnel for the task.

Reply
Adam Golightly link
7/12/2022 05:47:15 am

Thanks for explaining how old equipment can cost a lot because they are expensive to repair in both time and money because the project will be delayed. My cousin has been thinking about getting a crane for his current construction project because it requires moving some very heavy items. I think that renting a new crane could be really useful for him to be safer.

Reply
Iris Smith link
28/12/2022 06:18:52 pm

Thank you for pointing out that having equipment that is inexpensive to rent is one thing, but having equipment that frequently breaks down is quite another. My father wants to purchase tools for building. I'll recommend that he hire high-quality equipment rather than focusing solely on price. 

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases

    Archives

    June 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

    Copyright 2016 - The attached articles cannot be reproduced for commercial purposes without the consent of the author.
    The opinions expressed in the attached articles are those of the writer. It should be noted that projects are varied and different laws and restrictions apply which depend on the location of the contractor and the project. It's important that the reader uses the supplied information taking cognisance of their particular circumstances. The writer assumes no responsibility or liability for any loss of any kind arising from the reader using the information or advice contained herein.
    "I have what I consider some of the best books on construction management."


    Books are available from:
    Amazon.com
    Amazon.co.uk
    takealot.com

    kalahari.com
    Amazon.in
    Amazon.de
    Amazon.fr
    Amazon.it
    Amazon.com.au
    Powell's
    Fishpond
    uread
    bokus
    Amazon.ca
    Amazon.es
    Other retail stores


    Available in paperback or on Kindle

    ​"28 YEARS OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECT MANAGEMENT EXPERIENCE, DEVELOPING SUCCESSFUL CONSTRUCTION PROJECT MANAGERS AND BUILDING SUCCESSFUL CONSTRUCTION COMPANIES"

Construction Books

Successful Construction Project management
Building a Successful Construction Company
Construction Claims: A Short Guide for Contractors
Construction Management: From Project Concept to Completion
Construction Project Management: Tips and Insights
​
Build and Renovate Your Home With Your Eyes Wide Open
Book Reviews

Construction services

Construction Management Services
Paul Netscher
Construction Management Blog
​Home Improvement Blog

Contact
Developing Successful Construction Project Managers.

Building Successful Construction Companies.
30 years of construction project management experience
  • Construction Home
  • About Paul Netscher
  • +Construction Books
    • Successful Construction Project Management
    • Building a Successful Construction Company
    • Construction Claims
    • Construction Project Management: Tips and Insights
    • Construction Management: From Project Concept to Completion
    • An Introduction to Building and Renovating Houses
    • The Successful Construction Supervisor and Foreman
    • Designing your ideal home
  • Construction Management Services
  • Book Reviews
  • Contact
  • Blog | Construction Management
  • Site Map
  • Blog | Home Improvement
  • Index of construction articles
  • Useful Links
  • Index Home Improvement